This three book series seems to have been
written for the express purpose of turning them into movies. They are not what I would call, “well
written.” There were some grammatical
errors but the main objection I have is the amount of fluff. So much of the book simply does not need to
be there and the style makes much more sense if you believe that it was written
to be a movie. For example, many unimportant
things were mapped out in excessive detail.
It felt to me, even initially, that the book was a more a guideline for movie-makers
or meant to be little notes to actors. I
almost felt like the book was telling me how to feel rather than making me feel
that way. (Granted I have only read the
books once.) Ok, that may be true, you say,
but is that a bad thing? Well, maybe not
for most people, but I cannot categorize it as a good work.
Suzanne Collins set out to write something
that would sell, and she succeeded. At
first, I really had a problem with this idea.
I did not understand why a person would write something without trying
to create an excellent work. Of course,
then I realized that I’m the odd one
for thinking that a person would. People
write what there is a market for. That gives insight into the story and the majority of our
culture. I asked myself what it was
about these books that caused them to sell.
What was it that people found so appealing? Considering that the fan base is populated
primarily by teen girls, it seems realistic to assume that the drama and
romance is a large part of the appeal.
The main character pretends she is in love, in order to save her life, with
someone who really does like her while a good (and good-looking) friend back
home has to look on helplessly. Y’all,
this sounds like high-school drama! And
I never even went to school! (If you
wonder how I know, let me just say that despite my every effort, I could not
escape that ominous cloud of drama!) Romance
is something most teenage girls are looking for. Media, books, and celebrities all pound it
into their heads. How can we expect otherwise
when they are not taught or shown examples of anything else? But even sadder to me is the fact that many
mothers are just the same as these teenage girls. They may be married, but they still look to
media and literature to fill these romantic desires.
Friends, it is not healthy or good to be dwelling on this
kind of stuff. I find that the more I
dwell on it, the closer I find myself to sinning either through thoughts or discontentment. I sometimes catch myself wishing that I were
in a similar situation as a fictional character or fantasizing over something I
consider to be ideal. These indulgences steal
valuable time and encourage us to live anywhere except where and when we
do. They cause us to not live in the
present, which, by the way, is the only place where we can actually accomplish
anything.
“Keep your life free from the love of money and be content with what you have, for He
himself has said, ‘I will never leave you nor forsake you.’” Hebrews 13:5
Now before I go any farther, let me clarify a bit. I believe that this type of literature and
media can be quite dangerous, however, I am not saying that it is always
bad. I have read all three books and
have seen the movie three times. I looked
forward to the movie coming out and thought it was done well. I have had to be careful though that I did not
get too involved or concerned with it. I
don't want it to overtake my thought life or to become some sort of unstated standard. I look to scripture for that.
We are constantly surrounded with things that are wrong
or not best because we live in a sinful world.
However, we can still learn from them.
But in order to do so, we must be clear about them. We have to recognize and identify things
properly. (It is not right to use this idea
as an excuse to read trash or as a way to gratify our fleshly desires.) Re-labeling or redefining
things in order to ease our conscience or to classify something as acceptable is wrong. We have to evaluate everything according
to scripture so that we do not let sin slip into our hearts unnoticed. We must be careful to see things for what
they are and to react accordingly.
~ A Song of Joy
These both have been very good posts! I don't fit in either of the categories you've mentioned, or even the in between--I'm so out of it I don't have an opinion one way or the other. =) But I've enjoyed reading your thoughts.
ReplyDeleteFair enough! I wrote this post before I even had a blog and had not talked to many people about this topic... so I have found some like you since, I guess I am just saying in terms of the majority. I don't want to take so strong a view that I don't acknowledge others. Thanks for commenting!
ReplyDelete